An AI chart comes back looking finished: chords over bars, a key, a tempo. That is the risky part, because it looks finished whether it is right or not. The useful skill isn’t generating the draft. It is checking one quickly.
This post covers what the AI listens for and where its mistakes come from, then gives a routine for going through a draft before it reaches the band. For what makes a recording easy or hard, read which songs work best. This one picks up after the chart exists.
What comes back
A Chart in LeedSheet is the bars, the chords in them, the key and the tempo. A Vocal Chart adds the lyrics under the bars. It is not a melody transcription, and it is not an arrangement: hits, stops and fills are not on it.
Pulse first, then harmony
The analysis runs in two stages, and the order explains most of the errors.
- The pulse. The software finds the beats and decides which one starts each bar. Everything else hangs off this. If it picks the wrong beat as the downbeat, the chords can be exactly right and still land a beat early or late.
- The harmony. It works out which notes are sounding, picks the chord label that fits each stretch best, then settles the key from the whole song. Models like this have heard a lot of songs, and they lean toward progressions that are common. That helps nearly all the time. It also means the unusual chord, say a borrowed ♭VII in the chorus or a deliberate sus chord, is the one most likely to come back smoothed into something ordinary.
So when you check a draft, check the pulse before the chords, and look at the odd chords first.
What a wrong chart looks like
| What you see | Probable cause | Quick check |
|---|---|---|
| Right chords, each one early or late | The pulse picked the wrong beat to start the bar | Turn on Click and listen to it against the drums |
| Major where you hear minor, or the other way round | A dense mix hides the third | Play the root and the third on your instrument over the recording |
| C where the bass plays E | The inversion was missed | Listen to the bass on its own |
| Key says G, song feels like E minor | G major and E minor share the same notes | Decide where the song comes to rest |
| Two chords in a bar where you hear one | A passing note was read as a chord change | Slow the bar down and listen again |
A ten-minute check
- Settle the key first. Play the last chord of the song and hum the final note of the melody. If your ear says E minor and the header says G, decide which one the band will use before anything else, because everything is measured from it.
- Listen all the way through with the chart. Don’t stop. Mark every bar that bothers you and fix none of them yet. Finding trouble in one pass is faster than fixing as you go.
- Turn on Click. The metronome follows the beats the AI found. If it slides against the drums, the pulse is off and every bar after that point is suspect.
- Use the Chords button. It plays the chords on the chart so you can hear them against the recording. A wrong chord sticks out when the two disagree.
- Slow the flagged bars. The Speed control in the Mixer goes down to half speed. Listen for the bass, because its note is usually the fastest way to the chord.
- For a bar that won’t settle, split the stems. The bass stem shows you the root, and the guitar and piano stems help you tell major from minor. Stems bleed into one another, so treat them as a magnifying glass, not a clean photograph.
- Get a second opinion on the specific doubt. Another recording, a live version or a published chart can break a tie. Compare the one chord you are unsure about, not the whole song, and don’t treat any source as the truth.
- Let your hands decide. Play the chord over the recording. If your hands and the chart disagree, trust your hands.
To change a chord in Studio, double-click it and type it the way you would write it: Am7, G/B.
Re-running isn’t checking
A chart costs one credit for every five minutes of audio, counting a started block as a full one, so a four-minute song is one credit and a seven-minute song is two. Free includes 10 credits a month and takes audio up to five minutes. Pro raises that limit to ten.
It is tempting to run a song again hoping for a better answer. The second run is built from the same audio, so the weak spots tend to be the same ones. Ten minutes with the recording is a better use of the credit. Separating stems costs three credits, which is one more reason to keep them for the bars that won’t settle.
Give it better audio
For your own recordings, get the instruments that play the harmony loud enough to hear, trim any spoken intro, and record to a click if you can. A phone recording of the band works when the guitar and keys are audible. It doesn’t when the bass is a smear.
Questions
Can it chart a song I wrote?
Yes, as long as you have audio of it. A solo piano demo with a lot of rubato will place the bars less reliably than the same song played to a click, so check the bars first.
Why do live recordings take more correcting?
The tempo drifts and the crowd adds noise, and the pulse is the first thing to suffer. That is why the bars are the first thing to check. Trim any applause or spoken intro before the music starts.